

And I got a lot of help on that character (that thread has over 125 posts in it). I was only successful because I had a seasoned DM – which you guys don’t – and because I read about the system – both the actual rules and forum discussions – for a long time before I ever made a character. But it is not a good system for new players. Note that this is coming from an avid 3.5 player – I really do like the system. It’s entirely possible that a 3.5 game would go great, but I personally would consider it risky – more likely people will be confused and people will wind up with wildly varying power levels. Wizards had a very “ivory tower” design for it, and tried too hard to reward “system mastery” – which none of you have. It’s complicated and has a ton of rules, plus a lot of options that are (apparently intentionally) “traps” – stuff that looks good, but is really a waste of resources. I recommend against 3.5 (or Paizo’s “3.75,” Pathfinder, which is really not all that different). The first tabletop RPG I played was Dungeons & Dragons 3.5ed.

So I was wondering if anyone could point me in the direction of a fantasy RPG that has great storytelling potential and also the tactical combat possibilities of 4e. The thing is, although the game (4 ed.) has everything to please everyone, it has a lot of (somewhat unnecessary) rules. I've been reading the books for a while and told them to read the first chapters to get the basic idea.

So we're planning to get together and play a bit and experiment. Some of them loved the idea, while others were a bit more apprehensive, since we're basically a group of gamers. After recently moving to a new school, I made a few nerdy friends who didn't know D&D, so I've shown them some stuff. I've always wanted to play Dungeons and Dragons, but where I live it's more of an underground thing, so it was difficult to find other players. It is not currently accepting new answers or interactions. This question and its answers are locked because the question is off-topic but has historical significance.
